But When She Was Bad... She Was Horrid: Part 2

"When She Was Bad, She Was Horrid: Part 2" is the fifth episode of Season 3 of Road to Avonlea and the 31st episode overall.

Summary
Sara is confused for Jo Pitts by a gang of pick-pockets, who expect her to steal to restore money Jo stole from the gang. Gus makes a deal with his infamous father, Abe Pike, in order to free Sara from their clutches. Jo Pitts continues to wreak havoc on the King Family and terrorizes Hetty to the point of hysteria.

Cast
Main cast
 * Zachary Bennett as Felix King
 * Jackie Burroughs as Hetty King
 * Lally Cadeau as Janet King
 * Sarah Polley as Sara Stanley
 * Sarah Polley as Jo Pitts
 * Mag Ruffman as Olivia Dale
 * Gema Zamprogna as Felicity King

Recurring cast Guest cast
 * Peter Donaldson as Reverend Leonard
 * Denise Fergusson as Mrs. Tarbrush
 * Don Francks as Abe Pike
 * Barbara Hamilton as Eulalie Bugle
 * Michael Mahonen as Gus Pike
 * Colin O'Meara as Buck Hogan
 * Vivian Reis as Sarah Spencer
 * Tom Bishop as Man on Bike
 * Bill Copeland as Gentleman
 * Christian Tessier as Mole
 * Gordon Michael Woolvet as Rat